Many homeowners are unsure whether their fence needs a simple repair or whether a full replacement is the better long term solution. Both options can be suitable depending on the age, condition and structure of your existing fence, so it helps to understand the signs to look out for.

Start by checking the fence posts. These are the backbone of the entire structure. If one or two timber posts have become loose at the base, are slightly leaning or wobbling, or have rotted where they meet the ground, it is often possible to rescue the fence with repair spurs or by swapping out specific posts. However, if the majority of posts are unstable, soft to the touch, cracked or snapped at ground level, this usually indicates that the whole run is near the end of its usable life.

Next, inspect the panels or boards. Warping, significant bowing, broken rails, missing slats or widespread rot are clear signs that repairs will only offer a temporary fix. A few isolated issues – such as one damaged panel after a storm – are easy for us to replace individually. But if multiple panels are deteriorating at the same time, the cost of repeated repairs can quickly add up.

Also check the gravel boards if you have them. Concrete gravel boards can last decades, but timber ones often decay faster due to constant contact with moisture. Rotten gravel boards weaken the entire fence line because they allow damp to seep into the lower section of the panels. If most of the timber at ground level has decayed, replacement is usually the most sensible choice.

Consider the overall age of the fence too. Timber fencing that is more than 12–15 years old may have reached the point where repairs are no longer cost effective, especially in York’s damp climate. New fences built with strong posts, gravel boards and quality fixings offer far better long term value and will withstand weather pressure far more effectively.

During a survey, we assess every aspect of your existing fence and give honest advice about whether repairs will be reliable or whether a new installation will be more cost effective over time. Our goal is always to help you choose the option that provides the best value and longest lifespan for your garden.