Deciding whether to repair or replace an old fence depends on its condition, age, structural stability and the long-term cost-effectiveness of each option. In York’s climate, where strong winds and damp winters can take their toll, it’s important to assess damage properly so you get the best value for your money.

Start by examining the posts. If a fence is leaning, the most common cause is post failure. Timber posts often rot at ground level, and once the structural core has weakened, repairs usually provide only a short-term fix. In cases where one or two posts have failed but the panels are still in good condition, installing repair spurs can reinforce the structure. However, if several posts have failed, replacement is normally more cost-effective.

Next, look at the panels or boards. Warping, splitting, broken rails or extensive rot are signs that the timber has reached the end of its lifespan. Lightweight lap panels, in particular, deteriorate faster than closeboard fencing. Replacing worn panels piecemeal is possible, but if most need replacing, a new fence is usually the better investment.

Consider the stability of the fence line. If your old fence sways in the wind or creaks noticeably, it may be structurally compromised. In exposed areas, older fences can become unsafe and prone to collapse, especially if the footing depth was insufficient.

Cost is another factor. While repairs are cheaper upfront, repeated fixes quickly add up. A new fence, built with stronger materials such as concrete posts, gravel boards and heavy-duty boards, provides long-lasting durability and reduces long-term expenses.

Finally, think about appearance. If your fence is mismatched, heavily weathered or detracting from your garden’s overall look, replacement may add value and improve privacy and security.

During a survey, we can assess your fence carefully and explain whether repair or replacement offers the better outcome based on your budget, garden conditions and long-term needs.